When the Spanish women’s soccer team won the World Cup, Coach Luis Rubiales kissed Jennifer Hermosa on the lips. He said it was consensual. Here’s why it wasn’t.
Any kiss that happens when a woman’s head is held on either side by a man’s hands is not consensual. In essence he had her head in a vice grip. There is no consent when you can’t move your head. This was not a kiss, it was sexual assault. To those of you who think this is overblown, after all it was just a kiss, it’s time for some remedial education about the agency women have over their own bodies.
Equally troubling is what has happened since then. These events point to a culture of misogyny and sexism that is more than an isolated assault. It’s just that this one happened on international television.
Rubiales flatly refused to resign his position as Coach stating that he was the victim! The position of Coach is a powerful one in the lives of players. The one who has the power always has the responsibility to set and maintain an appropriate boundary. He claimed he was a victim of “false feminism” and said he was being “socially assassinated.” It implies that the women never complain about the other things that happen on the team and now that there has been a public sexual assault, their feminism is somehow feigned and therefor dismissed. What a crock. The issue here is that he is being held accountable for his behavior and he doesn’t like it one bit. Rubiales plays the feminist card to deflect attention from his own behavior and shift responsibility from him to Ms. Hermosa.
Rubiales, who is also the head of the Spanish Soccer Federation, said he should be more careful when acting or speaking on behalf Federation. Nowhere in his comment is any commitment to not sexually assaulting women. That speaks volumes about the culture of women’s soccer. He also refused to resign his position with the Federation. He has since been suspended.
The Spanish Soccer Federation released a statement on Ms. Hermosa’s behalf stating that it was a spontaneous mutual gesture. No, just no. He further disempowered her by putting words in her mouth and dismissing the comments she made directly to the media.
Rubiales made a comment that this was the same kiss he would give his daughters. Quick, someone call Child Protective Services. He is teaching his daughters that men can control women’s bodies and touch them how and when they wish. He is diminishing the agency his daughters have over their own bodies.
His “apology” is a typical non-apology. “I’m sorry you felt that way.” Women who are sexually assaulted do not need men apologizing for their feelings. It is demeaning. A real apology looks something like, “I am so sorry, I was totally out of line.”
There is a pervasive unspoken culture that men have access to women’s bodies, not needing their consent or permission. ATTENTION ALL MEN: You need permission to touch our bodies. And we deserve to set limits on how our bodies are touched without recrimination or name calling. Men need to take responsibility for their behavior and respect women’s bodies. Period.
As a woman in a historically male profession, I am continually astounded by the access men assume when it comes to my body. Over the last forty-five years I have been subjected to unwanted hugs and kisses, an arm around the waist or the shoulder, inappropriate comments about how I am dressed, or about particular parts of my body. When I speak up and set a limit I have been called a rabid feminist, a bitch, hypersensitive and not able to take a joke. This pervasive assumption of access to women’s body is the result of living in a patriarchal society. Men have more power, men are valued over women and women are objectified. Women are often professionally evaluated on the basis of our looks rather than our skills. While it is somewhat better now than it was forty-five years ago, there is still room for improvement.
So, should Rubiales resign? Absolutely. There needs to be a severe consequence for sexually assaulting a woman on international television. A clear message about the abusive nature of his behavior needs to be sent to the international community. Sexual assault has a lasting effect on women. It is time there was some consequence for men.
